“Should I be using a robo-advisor?” “Can I self-manage my accounts with AI now?” “Do I even need to pay for a financial planner anymore?” With AI becoming more visible in everyday life, there has been a surge of articles and videos claiming that artificial intelligence can take over your financial planning. But before taking anyone’s advice at face value, it is important to do your own research. So, let’s answer the big question: Should you use AI to help manage your finances?
AI has been around since the late 1950s and was originally designed to build machines that could think like humans. Today, we associate AI with new technology, job displacement, and major tools like ChatGPT or Claude. Artificial intelligence comes in many different forms, each built with a specific purpose. When it comes to financial management, the AI behind these programs is a type of generative AI, which is designed to create. The things it focuses on creating are writing, images, or audio and it does this by studying huge amounts of examples and data. When you interact with these programs, it will create a response based on what it believes you want to receive.
ChatGPT, for example, is designed and trained to understand language and generate human-like responses. It learns patterns from large amounts of text, allowing it to create new content rather than simply identify information.
A financial planner is a trained professional who helps individuals and families achieve their financial goals through personalized guidance. They are educated in key areas such as investments, retirement planning, insurance, risk management, estate planning, and ethics. Financial planners who hold the CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER® certification are also required to act in their clients’ best interests and complete continuing education every year. When deciding who should guide your financial future, ask yourself: Do I want a computer program that generates general responses - or a professional who provides advice tailored specifically to my life?
Before letting AI become your new financial mentor, here are some key considerations:
1. Personalization & Professional Insight
AI does not create personalized strategies tailored to your financial situation or your individual goals. A financial planner takes a comprehensive approach by examining your income, investments, insurance needs, taxes, and long-term objectives to build a plan that aligns with what matters most to you. Instead of focusing on one piece of your finances, they consider the full picture to help you make decisions that support your overall goals.
Imagine you are planning for retirement while also managing student loans, caring for an aging parent, and trying to buy a home within the next few years. A financial planner can review your full financial picture, help prioritize goals, coordinate with a CPA about tax implications, and work with an insurance professional to ensure your family is protected. AI, on the other hand, can only give general suggestions.
2. Ethical & Fiduciary Judgment
Financial planners are bound by ethical rules, regulatory standards, and fiduciary responsibility. They must consider long-term consequences and act in your best interest. AI cannot assume fiduciary duty, be held accountable, or ensure that its recommendations follow regulations. Generative AI models do not collect data from verified sources, instead they generate responses based on patterns in past data.
If you are deciding whether to roll over an old 401(k), a financial planner is required to give impartial advice by comparing your current plan’s fees and investment options regardless of whether they will directly manage the account or not. Their recommendation must be based solely on what is best for you. ChatGPT may generate a suggestion that sounds helpful but isn’t because it cannot actually analyze your financial details. It simply will predict what answer “sounds right” based on previous data, not what is genuinely in your best interest.
3. Information Security
AI tools cannot guarantee data privacy. If you share sensitive financial information with a chatbot and the company experiences a breach, your data may become exposed. Financial professionals, on the other hand, are required to follow strict legal and ethical standards to protect your information. Their systems, training, and regulations are designed to prioritize client security.
If a financial planning firm’s systems are ever compromised, they are legally required to notify clients, follow regulatory reporting procedures, and take steps to protect affected accounts. They must be transparent about what happened and what actions are being taken. If you share sensitive details such as account numbers or Social Security information with an AI chatbot and that platform experiences a breach, there is no requirement for the company to alert you directly. Your information could be exposed without your knowledge, and the AI tool has no obligation or ability to help you recover or secure your accounts.
AI may be a helpful tool for general information, but it cannot replace the guidance of a trained financial professional. Your financial life involves long-term goals, complex decisions, and personal circumstances that require thoughtful, customized planning. Unlike a financial planner, AI is not bound by ethical standards, regulatory requirements, or a duty to act in your best interest. Nor can it guarantee the security of the information you share. While AI will continue to evolve and play a role in the future of finance, it should be used with caution and never as the sole source for making important financial decisions.
Tags:
Reach out today. This could be the start of a great relationship.
Contact Us
